East Side Marios Reviews

East Side Marios has an overall rating of 3.7 based on 39 reviews. Customer feedback on East Side Marios is mixed: East Side Marios reviewers highlight positive aspects like delicious food, friendly staff, quick service and great atmosphere, which strongly appeal to food enthusiasts and casual diners. However, East Side Marios is often criticized for its limited parking, higher prices, inconsistent wait times and occasional menu changes.

3.7/5.0

39 reviews

5 Stars

9

4 Stars

3

3 Stars

3

2 Stars

3

1 Star

2

All East Side Marios Reviews (39)
hello_edna636
May 31, 2026
"Easy reservation and a smooth start"
In my experience, booking through eastsidemarios.com was really straightforward. We showed up a little early, and they still managed to get our table ready quickly. I didn’t run into any mix-ups or feel like we were stuck waiting forever. The whole seating process felt smooth, and the staff seemed organized and on top of things.
michelewilliams8285
May 26, 2026
"Not the best spot with kids"
I went here with my kids it wasn’t the most relaxing experience. They didn’t have crayons or anything ready to keep them busy, the staff seemed rushed, and the kids’ meals took a while to come out. It’s not even about expecting some huge kid-focused setup, but a few basic things would’ve made the visit a lot easier. Overall, it just didn’t feel very family friendly.
DarrellPippins_73
May 24, 2026
"Surprisingly Good About My Allergy"
I ordered from East Side Mario’s i was a little nervous because restaurants can be hit or miss with nut allergies. It was kind of busy, which usually makes me worry more, but the staff still double checked everything and didn’t make me feel weird about asking. I wouldn’t say I was totally relaxed the whole time, but I did feel like they were taking it seriously, which I really appreciated. Overall, I felt safe eating there and that matters a lot
POWERS
May 22, 2026
"Smooth drop-off with good communication"
The delivery handoff went really smoothly. The driver called when they were nearby and asked where to leave the food, which I appreciated because my building can be confusing. Just from their tone, I got the sense they were trying to make sure everything was easy and not rushed. The food was handed over quickly with no issues. Nothing fancy, but the clear communication made the whole drop-off simple.
hello_wanda669
May 18, 2026
"Decent takeout, but the mistakes are frustrating"
I’ve ordered takeout from East Side Mario’s through the site a few times now. The food usually gets here warm, and the delivery time is close to what they estimate, so that part has been fine. The thing that keeps getting to me is the order accuracy. One time they forgot the extra sauce I paid for, and another time I got the wrong pasta side. It’s not the end of the world, but it’s annoying when you’re already home, hungry, and kind of stuck with whatever showed up. Overall it’s okay, but I really wish they’d double-check the bags before sending them out.
TREJO
May 11, 2026
"Decent, but the wait was annoying"
The staff was nice enough, but the waiting got old fast. We waited longer than I expected for a table, and then the food took its sweet time too. For a weeknight, it felt way slower than it should’ve been. It wasn’t a bad experience, but I’d only go back if I had plenty of time and wasn’t already hungry.
OrlandoCronin
May 02, 2026
"Rewards really aren’t worth the hassle"
I signed up mostly for the rewards, but it’s been disappointing. The points barely show up, and when they do, the offers aren’t anything special. I reached out to support and it felt like I was getting replies from robots answering emails, just the same “please wait” type response over and over. Not really helpful at all...
irvingpreston4115
April 28, 2026
"Ordering online felt harder than it needed to"
I tried ordering dinner through eastsidemarios.com, the whole thing was more frustrating than I expected. The menus were slow to load, and anytime I tried to change something in my cart, it felt clunky instead of simple.
I also had to double-check my pickup time because it looked like it may have reset at one point, which made me a little nervous. Reading between the lines, the food itself was totally fine, but the website experience made it clear I probably wouldn’t rush to order that way again.
kathleen2001
April 24, 2026
"We booked this for a family party, but..."
We booked this for a family party, but the tables weren’t ready when we got there and the food took a while to come out. The staff seemed overwhelmed, so I felt bad for them lol, but it still made the whole experience kind of frustrating.
WilliamTucker
April 08, 2026
"Stopped in for dinner with my…"
Stopped in for dinner with my family after running a few errands, and overall it was a good visit. The place looked clean, tables were wiped down, floors looked fine, and even the washroom was decent, which I always pay attention to for some reason. It was a little busy, but still relaxed and not too loud, so it worked well for a casual meal. My kid was messing with the straw wrapper most of the time, so it clearly felt comfortable enough. Only small thing was our booth had a few crumbs tucked in the corner, but nothing major. I’d still go back...
hello_myrna582
March 28, 2026
"They handled my complaint quickly"
I had an issue and wasn’t sure what to expect, but the manager called me back fast and got it sorted out. Way better than some other places I’ve dealt with, where.....
loren_Hill77
February 25, 2026
"I felt misled going in. I expected…"
I felt misled going in. I expected decent service, but the staff barely checked on us the whole time, and whenever we asked for something, they acted like we were bothering them. It just made the whole experience feel uncomfortable
jasmineramsey0258
February 11, 2026
"So, yeah, we ordered from East..."
So, yeah, we ordered from East Side Mario’s i was kind of surprised by how much food we ended up getting for the price. Like, it wasn’t dirt cheap or anything, but the portions were really solid, and my pasta was enough to fill me up with, you know, some leftovers still sitting there after.
For a family dinner, it felt like a fair deal overall. There weren’t any random extra charges popping up either, which I definitely appreciated. I mean, all in all, I’d order from them again, especially if we wanted something filling without feeling like we totally overpaid.
love_Snethen95
January 17, 2026
"Super convenient spot"
Overall, I’d definitely go back. The location was really easy to get to, and parking ended up being simple too, which made the whole visit stress-free.
Richard_dennis92
January 17, 2026
"Pretty smooth, just a small billing hiccup"
Overall, the payment process was easy and everything went through fine. I did notice the bill had one extra drink on it at first, which was a little annoying. That said, the staff fixed it really quickly, so it wasn’t a big deal in the end
juan2003
January 10, 2026
"Pretty easy visit with my mobility needs"
I went to East Side Mario’s with some mobility needs, and it was an easy, easy visit. The entrance was manageable, there was enough room around the tables, and I didn’t feel like I was blocking anyone or stuck in a tight spot.

The staff were kind and helpful without making a big thing out of it, which I really, really appreciated. The accessible washroom was close enough too, so dinner just felt normal and comfortable.
SCHUBBE
January 09, 2026
"Great Pasta and Fresh Garlic Bread"
Ordered from East Side Mario’s last night i was mostly focused on the pasta. It showed up hot, super cheesy, and tasted really good. I did notice the garlic bread too since it was fresh and actually worth eating. Didn’t really have anything to complain about, so I’d definitely order it again.
joseph.Cook
December 31, 2025
"Big portions and plenty of choices"
I went to East Side Mario's and was sorta pleasantly surprised. The portions were bigger than I expected, and I ended up having leftovers to bring home, which is always a nice bonus.
The menu had a lot to choose from too, not just pasta, so it was easy for everyone at the table to find something they wanted. I’d definitely go back again...
Michael_triplett75
December 15, 2025
"The info was actually spot on"
I checked the menu and the hours before heading over, and everything ended up being accurate. It made planning dinner so much easier because there were no last-minute surprises or wasted time. it was such a relief to just show up and have things go smoothly
carolyn2001
December 08, 2025
"Coupon worked, but the cart acted a little suspicious"
I used a promo code on East Side Marios for a family takeout order last weekend, and once it finally kicked in, the discount came off at checkout like it was supposed to. So overall, no complaints there, the savings were real.

The only weird thing was the coupon didn’t show up right away, and I had to refresh the cart before it appeared. Maybe it was just a normal website glitch, or maybe the checkout page was testing my patience to see if I’d give up and pay full price. Either way, I caught it.

The food was ready close to the pickup time, and the discount made the order feel worth it. I’d definitely use their online coupons again, but I’ll be watching that total like a hawk before paying.

View More Reviews

Have a question about East Side Marios?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.